Journal · No. 018 · Essay · · 4 min read

You'll think naming won't work. Measure it anyway.

The first time someone told me to "just name the feeling", I nodded politely and thought: that's not going to do anything.

It turns out I was in good company. And it turns out I was wrong, in a way researchers have actually measured.

What naming does

In 2007 a team led by the psychologist Matthew Lieberman showed people photos of faces with strong expressions. Sometimes people picked a word for the feeling, such as "angry" or "scared". Sometimes they did other simple tasks with the same faces. When they picked the feeling word, the amygdala, a brain area tied to alarm, was less active, and a region in the front of the brain linked to putting things into words was more active (Putting feelings into words, Lieberman and colleagues, 2007). Psychologists call this affect labeling.

Why we don't believe it

A few years later Lieberman and colleagues asked a different question: do people know this? Across four studies, people looked at upsetting pictures and either labeled their feelings, tried to see the pictures in a different light, or did something else (Subjective responses to emotional stimuli during labeling, reappraisal, and distraction, Lieberman, Inagaki, Tabibnia and Crockett, 2011). Labeling lowered how distressed people said they felt.

Here's the part I find fascinating. People didn't expect labeling to help. And even after it had helped them, they still predicted that it would make them feel worse in the future.

So the tool works, and our gut keeps telling us it won't. That's a strange combination. It means that if I wait to feel convinced, I'll wait forever.

I think I know why we doubt it. Naming a feeling sounds like dwelling on it, and dwelling feels like the opposite of fixing. But a label isn't a long brood. It's one word, said once, and then I move on. Brooding goes round in circles. Naming draws a line around the thing and stops.

Trust the record, not the forecast

This is where the idea in Measure what you want comes in. My forecast of how something will feel is a guess. A record of how it actually felt is data. When the two disagree, I go with the record.

Teams work the same way. A Scrum team doesn't argue forever about whether a change will help. It tries it for a sprint and then looks at what happened in the retrospective. The Scrum Guide puts it bluntly: "inspection without adaptation is considered pointless" (The Scrum Guide, Schwaber and Sutherland, 2020). The reverse is true as well. Adapting without looking is just guessing.

A two-week test

So here's a small test you can run on yourself. Nothing scientific, just a tally in a notebook:

  • when something upsets you, rate it from 0 to 10;
  • write one plain word for the feeling. Not a story, one word: angry, ashamed, scared, lonely;
  • wait a minute and rate it again;
  • keep the tally for two weeks, then look at it. The whole thing takes less than two minutes a time.

If you're short of words, A small word list for naming what you feel is a good start. And if a number ever goes up after naming, note how big the feeling was to begin with. I'll come back to that in a later piece, because it matters.

Whatever your tally says, it's yours. It's a better guide than the voice that says "this is silly" before you've tried it.

One honest caveat

In the fourth study of that 2011 paper, labeling also took a little of the shine off pleasant pictures. Naming a feeling seems to cool it, whether it's good or bad. So I don't label my joy to death. When something lovely happens, I let it be lovely. The tool is for the weight, not the light.

And naming isn't the only thing that helps. In the same studies, seeing the pictures in a different light helped too. Naming is simply one of the quickest tools to reach for, and the one most of us underrate.

It's the same first step as in name it, tame it, and the same habit that sits behind Four names for a worry. The difference now is that I don't need to believe it first. I can just count.

I'm not a doctor, and this isn't therapy. It's a way of seeing that helps me. If you are struggling, please talk to someone you trust or a professional.

Your gut will say naming won't help. Don't argue with it. Name the feeling, and count.