Journal · No. 019 · Essay · · 4 min read

Name it while you face it

Naming a fear at a safe distance is one thing. Naming it while it's right in front of you is another, and that may be where it matters most.

In You'll think naming won't work I described lab studies where people named feelings about photos. But photos aren't life. Does naming still help when the frightening thing is real and close?

A study with a real spider

Katharina Kircanski, Matthew Lieberman and Michelle Craske put it to a hard test (Feelings into words: contributions of language to exposure therapy, Kircanski, Lieberman and Craske, 2012). They worked with 88 people who were very afraid of spiders and brought them, step by step, closer to a live tarantula. This is a standard kind of exposure therapy: face the fear gradually, in safety.

Everyone did the exposure, but they were split into four groups. One group described their feelings out loud while facing the spider, in sentences like "I feel anxious the disgusting tarantula will jump on me." One group put the situation in calmer terms, like "Looking at the little spider is not dangerous for me." One talked about something unrelated, such as the furniture at home. And one simply did the exposure without talking.

What happened a week later

A week later everyone was tested again, with a different spider in a different setting. The group that had named their fear showed less physical arousal, measured by how much their hands sweated. They also went slightly further towards the spider than the group who had talked about furniture, though that difference was small.

Here's the honest part. When asked, the naming group didn't report feeling less afraid than the others. Their bodies had calmed more than their words said. And the more fear and anxiety words people had used during the exposure, the more their physical response dropped.

I find that oddly encouraging. Naming didn't make the fear feel gone. It made the fear less in charge.

That gap between what we report and what our bodies do is worth knowing about. If you name a fear and still feel scared, it doesn't mean naming failed. Something may be shifting underneath, where you can't see it yet. That's one more reason to keep a record rather than trust the feeling of the moment.

Why the calmer sentence didn't win

The calm-sentence group surprised me. "It's not dangerous" sounds like the sensible thing to say. But telling yourself a fear is wrong while it's loudly there may be an argument you can't win in the moment. Saying what's true, "I'm scared of this", needs no argument.

I'm careful with this. One study is one study, and changing how you see a situation has plenty of support elsewhere. But it changed what I say to myself first. First the honest name. The calmer view, if I need it, comes after.

Doing this outside a lab

Most of what scares me isn't a spider. It's a phone call, a meeting, a letter I haven't opened. The same approach works:

  • do the thing in small steps, the way the spider was brought closer;
  • at each step, say what you feel, plainly, even out loud: "I'm anxious that this letter is bad news";
  • use real feeling words, and the more precise the better. The small word list helps, and so does the Feeling Wheel, a circle of feeling words created by Gloria Willcox (The Feeling Wheel, Willcox, 1982);
  • then take the next step anyway.

That last line is the whole point of name it, tame it. The name doesn't replace the step. It comes with you while you take it.

At work too

In Name it at work I wrote about saying the hard thing in the daily scrum. This is the inside version. Before a difficult conversation, I say to myself, in one line, what I'm afraid of. "I'm worried she'll think I failed." Then I walk in. The fear comes with me. It just doesn't get to drive.

And if the fear is about something I keep putting off, I pair this with a plan, as in Make a plan, and the nagging stops. Name the fear, set the time, then face it in small steps.

I'm not a doctor, and this isn't therapy. It's a way of seeing that helps me. If you are struggling, please talk to someone you trust or a professional.

Don't wait for the fear to leave. Name it, out loud if you can, and take the next step with it.