The right name, and how to test it
In the fairy tale, the queen wins the moment she says the little man's name. In real life, I've found, the trick is making sure it's the right name.
You may know the story. A miller's daughter is helped by a strange little man who spins straw into gold, and the price is her first child. She can only keep the child if she guesses his name. When she says "Rumpelstiltskin", his power is gone.
The principle of Rumpelstiltskin
In 1972 the psychiatrist E. Fuller Torrey compared psychiatrists with traditional healers from many cultures, in a book called The Mind Game: Witchdoctors and Psychiatrists. He argued that they share a few basic ingredients, and he put naming first. He called it the principle of Rumpelstiltskin. When a healer names what is wrong, Torrey wrote, "it says to the patient that someone understands, that he is not alone."
But Torrey added a condition that I think matters most. The name has to fit the person's own way of seeing the world. A name that comes from outside that world, he argued, is useless. The power isn't in any word. It's in the right one.
That matches what I've seen. A word from a textbook can leave me cold, while a plain word from my own life, like "stuck" or "left out", lands at once.
When a name does harm
More recently the psychiatrist Awais Aftab and the writer Alan Levinovitz looked at the other side of this (The Rumpelstiltskin effect, Aftab and Levinovitz, 2025). A label can comfort. It can also set up an expectation of getting worse, carry stigma, or quietly close off a person's sense that they can change anything.
I see small versions of this in myself. If I call a bad week "I'm just lazy", I've found a name, and it's a terrible one. It explains nothing and leaves no next step.
A harsh name is also sticky. Once it's said, it tends to stay, and it starts to explain everything. That's exactly when a name stops helping and starts deciding for me.
Test your label before you act on it
So I treat a name as a working guess, not a verdict. That's the small twist I've added to name it, tame it: name it, then check the name.
Checking matters because of a well-known habit of the mind. Once we have an idea, we tend to notice what supports it and skip what doesn't. Raymond Nickerson's review of the research called this confirmation bias "a ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises" (Confirmation bias, Nickerson, 1998). Once I've decided I'm lazy, every slow morning becomes proof.
My test has three questions:
- Does it fit the facts? Write down what actually happened, as on the Name it sheet, and see whether the name explains it. "Lazy" doesn't explain why I worked late three evenings that week.
- What else could it be? Write at least one other name. "Tired." "Avoiding one specific task." "Unsure what's expected of me."
- Does it point to a step? A good name suggests a next move. "Avoiding one task" points to the task. "Lazy" points nowhere.
Then I pick the name that fits best, act on it for a few days, and look again. If the step helps, the name was probably close. If not, I rename. Scrum calls this inspect and adapt. A scientist would call it testing a hypothesis. Either way, the name stays open to correction.
It's the same care I try to take with a because, as in Add a "because", and with a problem, as in Name the problem before you solve it.
The oldest naming story
The Bible has a naming scene near its very beginning. God brings the animals to Adam "to see what he would call them: and whatsoever Adam called every living creature, that was the name thereof" (Genesis 2:19). I've always noticed the word see. Naming there isn't a guess thrown out in a hurry. It's attention: looking at the creature in front of you and finding the word that fits.
That's the spirit I want. Not the first name that comes to mind, and not the harshest one. The truest one I can find, held lightly enough to change.
I'm not a doctor, and this isn't therapy. It's a way of seeing that helps me. If you are struggling, please talk to someone you trust or a professional.
A name has power, so test it. Keep the one that fits the facts and points to a next step.